NFL Week Eleven Winners and Losers

The eleventh week of the NFL season was both chaotic and fun by various turns. The upsets rocked not just the football world but the expected playoff pictures in both conferences. There is still a lot to process and breakdown because most fans and analysts didn’t expect so many storylines. It is time to break down the best and worst of week eleven.

Winners: Davis Mills

After C.J. Stroud IV was injured two weeks ago, many wondered if Houston could salvage their playoff chances with veteran backup quarterback Davis Mills named starter. Mills is now undefeated after both his starts. Those wins were both against divisional opponents.

Davis Mills completed 26 of 41 passes for 274 yards, a touchdown and a 90.9 quarterback rating. His scoring pass to receiver Nico Collins gave the Texans their first lead of the game. Mills also led two critical scoring drives in the fourth quarter to tie and then take Houston’s second and last lead.

The AFC South now has an opportunity to have two teams make the playoffs. The Texans winning two important division games without their starting quarterback keeps them in the postseason picture before December.

Sean Tucker

Tampa Bay’s controversial loss in Buffalo (more on that later) dampened a lot of positive talk on the Buccaneers’ running game. Since Bucky Irving’s absence for a few weeks, Tampa Bay couldn’t afford a one dimensional performance in a pivotal road game at Buffalo. A runningback like Sean Tucker had to step up and play well.

That is exactly what Tucker did. The sophomore had 19 carries for 106 yards and two touchdowns. He also had two catches for 34 yards and another score. Sean Tucker had 18 of the Buccaneers 32 points before the Bills pulled ahead and forced Tampa to commit more mistakes.

If the Buccaneers are going to have a solid playoff run, they need the running game to step up more. Sean Tucker brings a lot of skill and grit many teams covet in a starting back. Once Bucky Irving returns, Tampa Bay should use both to throw more teams off balance.

Pittsburgh Steelers

It has been a rough last four weeks for Pittsburgh. The Steelers were able to beat the NFL-best Colts, but lost to Cincinnati, Green Bay and Los Angeles. In all three losses, Pittsburgh’s defense gave up at least 25 points and the offense was either great or terrible. On Sunday, the good Steelers showed up.

Both quarterbacks Aaron Rodgers and Mason Rudolph combined for 243 yards, two touchdowns and a 112 quarterback rating. Runningback Kenneth Gainwell had seven catches on eight targets for 81 yards and both scores. The offense played well against a historically bad Bengals defense.

Pittsburgh’s defense played their best game of the season. While they sacked veteran quarterback Joe Flacco once, the Steelers gave up less than 200 passing yards. Safety Kyle Dugger sealed a win with an interception return for a touchdown late in the third quarter. Cornerback James Pierre also returned a Noah Fant fumble for a touchdown.

Many wonder if Pittsburgh can keep both their division lead and win the AFC North late in the season. If the Steelers heat up or play like they did Sunday, there is no doubt they win the division.

Mark Andrews

Baltimore’s second game against Cleveland was almost unwatchable. Any updates that appeared showed the Browns and Ravens in a slugfest. No matter which team won, it was a big deal if Baltimore tight-end Mark Andrews either scored or set the franchise record in receiving yards. He did both on Sunday.

Andrews broke former Raven great Derrick Mason’s receiving yards record with three catches for 32 yards. Given how tough Cleveland’s pass defense is, Mark Andrews wasn’t going to have a breakout performance. Yet he did clinch the record five plays into the game. Andrews also had the play of the game when he lined up for a Tush Push play, but faked the run up the middle, and ran for a 35 yard touchdown. It shocked audiences and sealed the Ravens fourth straight win.

Losers: Washington Commanders

Watching Washington play American gridiron football the past two weeks heading into week eleven was awful. Two playoff favorite teams went into the DMV and pummeled the Commanders. Washington dealt with serious injuries and ejections from fighting. Sunday’s loss in Madrid was another low, but in different ways.

Commissioner Roger Goodell decided audiences in Spain should be treated to a lowly Washington versus Miami matchup. In the first NFL game played in Iberia, the Commanders played the Dolphins to a deadlock until a breakout third quarter. Backup quarterback Marcus Mariota’s 20 yard touchdown pass to Deebo Samuels finally gave the team some hope and their first lead of the game.

Washington’s defense had a better game, but they gave up a tying touchdown to start the fourth quarter. Despite some breakout plays by Mariota the next two possessions, the Commanders couldn’t score because of a turnover on downs and a missed field goal attempt. That meant overtime. Miami intercepted Marcus Mariota the first play of overtime, and finished their only drive of the quarter with a field goal.

It’s one thing to get blown out two straight weeks in the worst ways possible. To go overseas and lose an unwatchable, close game against another bad team in overtime feels worse.

NFL referees, beginning with Alex Moore and his crew

Here it is. Overall officiating was a hot mess in most of Sunday’s games, but there was none worse than referee Alex Moore and his crew in Buffalo. Most pundits will laud Bills quarterback Josh Allen for his six touchdown performance and conveniently ignore certain parts of the game that led to some of those scoring opportunities.

The errors and bad calls started late in the second quarter. A questionable roughing the passer penalty on Tampa Bay gave Buffalo a fresh set of downs a minute left in the half. The Bills offense capitalized with a 52 yard touchdown three plays after. On the Buccaneers first drive of the second half, tight-end Cade Otton had a nine yard gain that was close to the first down marker. CBS’s J.J. Watt said it looked like a first down to him, and audiences saw the side and overhead views. It looked like a first down. Not only did the referees not look into the play past a digital camera measurement, head coach Todd Bowles let them off the hook by not challenging the play.

The most egregious call came late in the fourth quarter when the Buccaneers defense finally stopped a crucial Buffalo drive. On a third and four, Tampa Bay held the Bills to what should have been a field goal attempt. However, Alex Moore threw a flag for a facemask penalty, and that led to an automatic first down and 15 yards for Buffalo. Everyone who saw the replay all said the same thing: there was no penalty because the hands never went inside the mask. The defender’s hand hit the helmet screw on the side. Two plays later, Allen and the Bills scored another touchdown.

Yes, there are always calls with which viewers, refs and fans in the stands will disagree. Loudly. NBC and NFL broadcasters disagreed on referee Alex Kemp’s pass interference call on Detroit cornerback Rock Ya-Sin against Philadelphia receiver A.J. Brown late Sunday night that sealed an Eagles win. The call was considered so bad that Yahoo!’s Jay Busbee wrote an article on how receivers drawing pass interference calls is their revenge for the NFL’s complicated catch rules. John Hussey’s crew missed several holding calls in Los Angeles could have impacted Seattle’s last field goal attempt. When sports outlets like ProFootballNetwork show disproval over calls like Otton’s failed first down conversion, it can only make the audience’s distrust of the officials grow.

Jonathan Gannon

One would think after November ninth’s brutal loss in Seattle, head coach Jonathan Gannon may have found ways to inspire confidence against a division rival Arizona tends to play their hardest and best games against the following week. Apparently, Gannon did nothing to inspire confidence with his roster, since the Cardinals were blown out again in another embarrassing loss to San Francisco. This time it was at home.

The 49ers had a double digit lead for almost three quarters. While the score was terrible, the worst part for Arizona was the number of penalties. The Cardinals committed 17 penalties for 130 yards. According to Theo Mackie of the Arizona Republic, it was a new record in over a century of the team’s franchise history. Broadcaster Kevin Kugler said close to half-time that the Cardinals committed 13 in one half. The mistakes gave San Francisco more scoring opportunities and nullified touchdowns and positive plays for Arizona.

Two blowouts against division rivals certainly should have Jonathan Gannon on the hot seat and fighting for his job the remainder of the season. If the Cardinals can’t improve and continue playing like this heading into Christmas, there will be no doubt about Gannon’s job status.

Klint Kubiak

The same people who heaped praise on Bills quarterback Josh Allen for a six touchdown game and did not consider the officiating issues sound like same ones dumping vicious criticism on Seahawks quarterback Sam Darnold for a four interception game without considering it wasn’t all on him. It is most certainly true Darnold’s four turnovers were a headache and held Seattle back in what may have been the most important NFC west divisional game all season. However, a lot of Seattle’s game plan should not have involved him throwing the ball on five step drop-backs or in shotgun formation.

Serious analysts said prior to Sunday’s game that the Seahawks dual running game and offensive line would determine which team won. Both areas have been serious concerns every time Seattle has played Sean McVay’s Rams. Backup center Olu Oluwatimi’s first start of the season was in the most important NFC West game this year. Offensive coordinator Klint Kubiak should have emphasized that runningbacks Zach Charbonnet and Kenneth Walker III get the ball two of every three downs. The running game is great for offensive linemen because they go into attack mode and lead with pushes against the defense. Two quality running backs make the ground game harder to stop. It also leads to play action passes (where the quarterback fakes the hand-off to runningbacks and then settles in to pass), which could have and should have been encouraged.

Kubiak also casually ignored high risk throws. Sam Darnold has thrown in triple and quadruple coverage a few times the last few games, and while accuracy and luck have bailed him out, that should have been stressed weeks ago. It wasn’t until the third quarter and the last two drives of the game that Darnold was more careful with the ball. Coincidentally, that’s when the running game got going and gave Los Angeles issues.

Seattle will regret not winning Sunday’s game for a lot of reasons. The possibility of rookie offensive guard Grey Zabel landing on injured reserve is season altering. If there had been a better offensive game plan from the offensive coordinator, a lot of upcoming issues would be non-existent.

Note: NFL’s Winners and Losers will not be published next week due to writer, editor and publisher personal reasons and necessary time off. Publications will resume around the conclusion of week 13.